All good points. I did order this directly from Tucson Harley-Davidson, in person, walked into the store and went to the parts counter. They had to order it from their Vintage Parts division, apparently, but they did have it in stock. The date on the box it came in shows 2019.
I think I will take a bit of emory like you suggested on a popsicle stick and just clean up some of the really bad stuff and run it. I had the same issue with my 1125CR! I took the rear wheel in for a new tire and it came back with minor nicks and damage to the sprocket. Next time, I think I'm just going to remove the sprocket to avoid that altogether. Thanks for the responses!