Your in the wrong place for cons
. I have the 12Ss and have to say the first 1000 miles I was not sure I made the right choice in a bike. The V-twin was rough and the bike felt different in every way than the Jap bikes I have owned.
After 5k miles I will never own another bike...............
Pro's
Low maintenance cost, No valves to adjust, no chain to replace (50k on the belt) and no adjustment on said belt. No radiator fluid to flush or replace. Fuel injected, air cooled. The handling is awesome and the Torque is absolute fun. Its like being in a built hot rod and stomping the gas, your body gets planted in the seat from the G forces. Same with the Buell, twist the grip and hold on. The torque is very flat across the rpm range meaning that from the crack of the throttle to red line its pulling about the same. The saying is the Buell pulls like a freight train and that no exaggeration. The seating is upright and comfortable more of a sport touring feel with an natural balance when at speed (no pressure on the wrist or lower back). As for the Ss, I'm 5'10" and wanted the extra leg room and seat room for the wife so I got the Long. I plan on doing some touring at some point so I wanted the most room I could get. Your also getting into a small group of enthusiast that have made a nice little community and are willing to help you out when ever or were ever you need. You don't have the same bike everyone else has. Its unique and stands out of the crowd. 50 to 60 MPG depending on our riding style and your upkeep on the bike. Of course adding a race ECM Pipe ect. will lower that some.
Con's
The heat from the motor gets bothersome at times during the summer in traffic. The after market support is limited to a few suppliers and options for stuff are slim. You cant just run up to the local sportbike shop to get a set of mirrors or break pads you have to order them on line. The good thing is the online Buell shops are very good and most own Buells so your buying from fellow riders. Your paying for as much as a Jap liter bike and not getting the same top end performance and speed. The Buell lives in the corners and back roads where it shines.
I can't really compare the Buell to my other bikes,FZR 750, R-6, Drz400SM, because its comparing apples to oranges but the Buell is much funner to ride and a lot more comfortable on long trips.
I guess comparing Buell to Brand X is hard because everyone has different taste and comfort levels. After 36 years I know what I like and the Lightning Long is the bike for me.