John, I really don't know what they did, I was working under the assumption they knew what they were doing...
So yeah there are a few knicks (most people would never even have brought it up), but I'm super anal. This is the only work I don't do myself due to obvious reasons (equipment), so I've come to accept knicks. Even on my vehicles it happens every time. It's not worth it to me to make them repowder coat the parts, it's just too much hassle and time. If it was worse yeah, but it's very minor.
The people that I talked to were actually very good and nice, they charged me half price since they couldn't balance them and they were very apologetic, and good to talk to. I really didn't have any issue with them other than the scuffs which is par for the course in my opinion for any service.
I actually told them I DIDN'T want them balanced, but they talked me into it. Then when finished said they couldn't do it, so I was honestly fine with that. I don't like the weights on the wheels, and my last set was not balanced and I never had any issues and have topped the bike out a couple times. Hopefully I'll have similar results this time...
They did offer to take them to another shop down the street for balancing, but I told them I'm going to try them as is and if I have issues I'll come back.
The only thing that pisses me off is the knicks, but oh well, like I said I've come to live with it anytime I have anybody work on anything that I have, which is not very often.
The other thing good about them is they are the only shop (very literal statement) in the area that gave me a reasonable price on both tires and mounting. Other shops either wanted like 50% more than I could buy online for tires or if I bought online they jacked up the labor by 200%.
Ya'll have a merry christmas as well, I appreciate the input! I am hoping to be done reroofing my house shortly after the holidays and have some time for the buell again. I have very little to do to wrap up my headlight project, and can be riding more again. Here I am bitching about other people doing bad work, and I found a screw on my roof yesterday during a storm leaking like a SOB. Went on the roof today and turns out I installed a screw without a gasket DOH! lol.