Not really fair to compare an air-cooled twin to a I-4, last I checked the XB12R ran in "superstock C" and the I-4 supersports were running in "Superstock B and Superstock A".. Just saying. For me, I find the XB12R to be a much more radical ride on the streets without getting yourself killed or losing your liscense, just more fun and you can flick it right over. A lot of the I-4s I see on the streets have huge chicken strips on them. Don't get me wrong, in the right hands a I4 is a bad ************ but the average guy I run into sees my tires and goes "FUUUCK" because I barley have any chicken on my FRONT and none on my rear... and this was mostly done at legal street speeds. Im not sure if I could hold these lean angles at these low speeds on R6 or a R1.. maybe, but Im just not sure.. something about the size of a XB just does it for me. Ive been on faster bikes in the past but Im not sure they made me a better rider..XB made me BETTER.. I can see it and I can feel it.
As for the weight of the XB, I don't think its heavy..and if you got the money you can shave a lot of weight off of a XB still.. Race battery saves 9 lbs, and magnesium wheels save another 10 I think it was.. exhaust you can drop some too.. there is still room to play with in there.. rider weight could be a factor also,, Im only 5'5" and 150lbs.. XB is perfect size and weight for me.
I was running a drilled out airbox for a while, I went back to stock because the stock cover ran a lot stronger at street speeds with the race ecm..vs a drilled out one. Like others are saying, they run too lean.