Well, we are very pro american in my house (though i drive an Audi, i only bought it because i wanted a car that did well in the snow, that i could afford, and i'd rather support the germans than the japanese), and my dad rides a 99 super glyde and i ride my '03 lightning. My dad LOVES my bike and thinks its really awesome how something could be that quick and still get over 50mpg, but he's a pretty big guy (6'4 about 350lbs next to my 5'10 and 170) so he can't really get comfortable on a buell. He acknowledges all the engineering that Erik put into his bikes though, and really wishes there was something he could ride that had a little bit of buell at heart. He was even talking about buying a buell engine to swap into his bike at some time here, but his health is becoming worse and worse. The thing i always point out about Buells though is that they are the most american bike you can buy. Most HD bikes nowadays are made in mexico, where buells (even the rotax engines) were made right in wisconsin. I don't really have a problem with buying products from mexico, and i'd rather support them than the japanese, but in all honesty, i have my eyes set on several other bikes at the moment, and unless it came to me for real cheap, i don't think id ever buy ANY harley. It's not for the same reasons as probably everyone else here, but i just don't have an intrest.
Now, if harley used all the machines and materials that buell used, but just stuck there name on it, i might buy one, but it would only be if i knew they would keep the bike going for a while so i'd have replacement parts availability. They would have to price it pretty low though, because if i had to spend a few more clams to get a bike with Buell's name on it, i certainly would.