Address a few things:
1.) I highly doubt any BuellForums.com member wishes any negative energy toward BuellXB.com. Like many are saying, it is directed at the owner of BuellForums.com, as he tossed us in the trash (or at least we thought he did). We are (or at least I am) grateful that the BuellXB.com owner is helping us through this transition.
2.) Regarding negative comments about the interface of BuellXB.com, just offering feedback based on our experiences. It was a question that was asked, so people are answering truthfully.
3.) When I first started searching for a Buell Forum, I landed on BadWeatherBikers.com. I imagine mainly because I was searching for Blast info. I found BuellXB.com next, but the Blast activity was limited. I found BuellForums.com and you already know how I feel about that. You can also see my posts here are limited because of that. I rarely used BadWeatherBikers.com because the interface was horrible. Good info., horrible interface.
4.) Buell is basically still alive (erikbuellracing.com). There should be future Buells (RS, RX, SX, AX, and more). I totally understand the commitment to BuellXB.com. If I had an XB (which I'll soon have half of one - Blast Joke
) I could see the value in this site. Although:
If I wanted to buy some strawberries, I'd go to strawberries.com.
If I wanted to buy some fruit, I'd go to fruit.com.
If I wanted to buy some oranges, I'd go to fruit.com.
If I wanted to buy strawberries, I could alternatively go to fruit.com.
If I wanted to buy some lettuce, I'd go to lettuce.com.
If I wanted to buy a banana, head of lettuce, peanuts, and a carrot, I'd go to produce.com.
I don't care as much about the name as I do the content, but if we are talking long term, I think BuellForums.com is the better option. I understand BuellXB.com is basically branded. What happens when all the new Buell 1190RS owners want to find a forum dedicated to their bike, maybe go to BuellRS.com? And what about all the Buell XB owners that move onto a Buell 1190RS, but still like their Buell XB chatter, should they stay at BuellXB.com, but also go to BuellRS.com? Or they could stay at BuellXB.com, but maybe the content for the RS isn't as good because all the RS owners don't come to BuellXB.com because that forum seems as though it is dedicated to the Buell XB because they think that is not dedicated to the new RS, so why would they waste their time with BuellXB.com? (yes, run on sentence).
I feel if you have the opportunity to rebrand to BuellForums.com, you should do it!
Another example, I could have HarleyDavidsonForums.com and have all the Harley people come. Or I could have HarleyDavidsonXL1200.com, and only have people wanting to see information on the XL1200.
I understand the dedication, but BuellForums.com will out live BuellXB.com in the long run (name wise). AND, I highly doubt the dedicated BuellXB.com Members will leave.
5.) There were a lot of elements in BuellForums.com that made the experience valuable.
a.) The chat box. It was just handy when needed. Ask a quick question, send out a quick note, etc. It was fun. Not only was there a chat box at the top of the page, but also a completely alternative full chat session, if you wanted to access it. (and nobody really did unless they were drinking
).
b.) Thank You and Groan. Rarely did anyone use groan, but each user had the opportunity to thank the poster for their useful information specific to that post. It did add to their reputation, but more importantly, it was encouraging and positive. When you thanked a poster, directly below the post would be the list of people who thanked you. As you could imagine, EZBlast, Jet-Lee, Pierce, Thump-E, and a few more had plenty of thank you's. For a newb to receive a thank you was very welcoming, supportive, and motivating.
c.) The images were loaded on the page in a small format, only when you would scroll over the images were would they expand to a larger size and you could browse through them without leaving the thread. You could always click on the image and it would open up in a new tab or new window.
d.) YouTube Videos easily embedded into the post.
e.) PM was better. All the RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:RE in the BuellXB.com PM is a little ridiculous.
f.) There was a actual private chat opportunity, similar to Facebook. That was active shortly before our balls were stomped on by the BuellForums' owner (or so we thought).
g.) Awards. Similar to your ranking, but more involved. Things like Blast Owner, Site Contributer, Gun Owner, Marines, etc., just added some personality.
h.) About pages were more personable. You could write on their 'wall', or leave comments, look at images or videos they uploaded, links, etc. Just more information in general.
i.) The Look! This forum, like I said before, just looks like another forum. I understand the argument of page loading, but I never had issues loading a page at BuellForums.com. And like jetlee stated, you had the option to change what you would like to see. I've never had any load issues with my phone unless I was on 3G. Still loads, but if there are pictures, it is a bit slower, but nothing I would complain about. 3G is old technology
. And Page Load Time? Is it really that different? I don't think so. If anything, I always felt BuellXB.com was a bit slower, or clunky-er. I've seen basic HTML sites load slower than sites with richer content. If the code was written poorly, it will run poorly.
j.) There is more, but this is getting a bit long
.
Some of this may seem silly, and to an extent it is, but it added to the experience, a community.
Ultimately, I really don't care about anything but getting that content.